Gap insurance costs about $2 to $5 per month if you add it to your existing auto policy, which usually works out at $20 to $60 a year. It costs $400 to $1,000 as a lump sum if you buy it in the dealership’s finance office, and that amount is usually rolled into your car loan, so you pay interest on it too. A $700 dealer policy at 7% over 60 months really costs around $830. The coverage is functionally the same. Carrier gap is roughly 7 to 10 times cheaper. And if you already bought the dealer version, you can cancel it for a pro-rata refund in all 50 states.
How Much Is Gap Insurance Per Month? : Key Facts at a Glance
| Question | Short answer |
|---|---|
| From your auto insurer | $20 to $60 a year, roughly $2 to $5 a month |
| From a credit union | $200 to $400 one time |
| From a dealership | $400 to $1,000 lump sum, usually financed |
| True cost of a financed $700 dealer policy | About $830 at 7% over 60 months |
| Is the coverage different? | Functionally the same. The price is the difference. |
| Can you cancel dealer gap? | Yes. Pro-rata refundable in all 50 states. |
| Free-look period | Typically 30 to 60 days for a full refund |
| Refund timeline | Usually 4 to 8 weeks from a dealer |
| Does State Farm sell gap? | No. It offers Payoff Protector on its own auto loans. |
| Requirement to add it | You must carry comprehensive and collision |
The Same Coverage Has Two Prices, and You Picked One While Tired
Here is the whole article in a single comparison.
Ring your auto insurer and ask them to add gap to your policy, and it costs roughly $20 to $60 a year, which works out at about three dollars a month appearing quietly on your next bill.
Buy the identical protection in the dealership’s finance office and it costs $400 to $1,000, charged as a single lump sum and almost always rolled into your car loan, which means you are now paying interest on your insurance for the next five to seven years.
The coverage is functionally identical, because both pay the difference between what your insurer says your car was worth and what you still owe the lender after a total loss. The only real difference is the price and the paperwork.
Then there is the timing. The gap pitch does not happen when you walk in, but in the finance office, after you have already spent hours negotiating and agreed the price, at the point where you have decided you are buying the car and simply want the keys. That placement is not accidental, it is the entire design.
So if you are reading this because of a nagging feeling that you were sold something in that little room, your instinct is entirely correct, and the remainder of this page concerns what you can do about it now.
How Much Does Gap Raise Your Payment?
This is the mechanism that makes the whole thing work, and it is worth understanding properly, because nobody ever really agrees to spend $700 on gap insurance. What they agree to is twelve dollars a month.
Here is the arithmetic. A $700 gap policy financed over 60 months at 7% APR works out at roughly $12 a month, and by the time the loan is finished it has cost you approximately $830 in total. A $600 policy at 7% over five years costs about $660.
Twelve dollars a month sounds like nothing next to a $500 car payment, which is precisely why it gets quoted that way. The same product from your insurer runs about $3 a month with no interest attached at all, because you are not borrowing money in order to buy insurance.
You never saw the $700, you only ever saw the $12, and that is the trick, except it is not really a trick at all because it is simply how financing anything works. The problem is that nobody tells you the other number exists.
Why Do Dealerships Push Gap Insurance?
Because it is where the money is, and the car is not.
The margin on selling you the actual vehicle is often surprisingly thin, since negotiating the sticker price is the part everybody prepares for, and dealers know it. The finance and insurance office, where they sell gap, extended warranties, paint protection and tyre cover, is a far more profitable department. Those products carry high margins, and gap in particular is marked up heavily because most buyers have no idea it is available for a tenth of the price elsewhere.
That is the honest answer to a question a lot of people ask in a slightly different form: how much does a car salesman make on a $30,000 car? Often less than you would guess on the car itself, which is exactly why the conversation does not end when you agree the price, because the profitable conversation is the one that starts afterwards.
None of this is illegal or even unusual, since dealers earn commissions on gap sales and are entitled to. But the industry knows exactly what it is doing on timing. As one insurance agency puts it plainly, dealerships present gap after long financing negotiations, when buyers are fatigued. Convenience is the product actually being sold, and the cover itself is almost incidental.
Do I Get Money Back If I Cancel My Gap Insurance?
Yes, and this is the most actionable thing on this page, despite hardly anybody knowing it.
Dealer-sold gap is refundable on a pro-rata basis in all 50 states. If you cancel within the free-look window, typically 30 to 60 days, you get a full refund, and after that you get back the unused portion of the term.
There is generally no deadline for asking, but the refund is calculated from the cancellation effective date rather than the date you first considered it, meaning every month of delay is money you never recover.
The situations where you are almost certainly owed a refund and have not claimed it:
- You paid off the loan early, which means the entire remaining gap term is unused premium sitting with someone else.
- You refinanced. That counts as a payoff of the original loan, and your old gap policy does not transfer to the new lender.
- You traded the car in, because gap on a car you no longer own does nothing at all.
- You sold it privately, which has exactly the same effect.
- You now have positive equity, because two to three years into a five-year loan most depreciation curves have flattened enough that your balance and the car’s value are roughly equal, at which point gap has no remaining function.
How to actually do it:
- Contact the dealership’s finance and insurance department and ask for the cancellation form. Some require it in writing, so ask for the specific form and where to send it.
- Provide your current odometer reading, along with proof of payoff if the loan has been settled.
- Keep a copy of absolutely everything you send them.
- Expect the process to take 4 to 8 weeks. If a loan balance still remains, the refund goes to the lienholder, whereas if the loan is paid off it comes directly to you.
If you bought gap through your insurer instead, it is far simpler, because one phone call is enough and the unused premium usually appears as a credit on your next bill, with no form, no cheque and no waiting.
One name to watch for: some dealers brand this product EPO, for Extended Protection Option, rather than calling it gap. It is the same product with the same cancellation rights and merely a different word on the paperwork, so do not let the label convince you it is something else.
Can a Dealership Refuse to Cancel Gap Insurance?
No, and if one tries, you have somewhere to go, because your right to a pro-rata refund of unused gap coverage is real and some states write it into statute explicitly. Texas, for example, requires dealers and lienholders to provide a prorated refund of unused dealer gap when you cancel, pay off the loan, or trade in the vehicle, under Chapter 1153 of its Insurance Code.
What you are more likely to encounter is not outright refusal but friction. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau has documented that cancellation delays and slow refund timelines are a recurring problem with these products, and that administrative errors are a frequent finding. That is a federal regulator saying the process is often worse than it should be.
So do this: put the request in writing, keep a copy, and note the date. If nothing has happened after eight weeks, follow up in writing again, and if it still stalls, file a complaint with your state’s Department of Insurance, which regulates these products and takes exactly this kind of complaint. In Texas that is tdi.texas.gov, and every state has an equivalent.
A complaint to a regulator is free and takes about fifteen minutes, and it tends to move things that phone calls simply do not.
Is Gap Insurance Paid Monthly or Yearly?
It can be either, and whichever one you have tells you immediately where you bought it.
Through your auto insurer, gap is an endorsement on your existing policy, billed exactly the way your policy is, so it simply becomes part of your monthly or six-monthly premium at around $20 to $60 a year.
Through a dealership, it is a single lump sum charged at signing and covering the life of the loan, so if you financed it you are indeed paying monthly, but as loan principal with interest attached rather than as an insurance premium.
Through a credit union, usually a one-time fee of $200 to $400, and some include it free with certain loan products. Worth asking, because credit unions tend to price it transparently and cancel it without drama.
Gap Insurance and Gap Waiver Are Not the Same Product
Here is a distinction that matters legally, and that almost nobody bothers to explain.
What your insurer sells you is gap insurance: a genuine insurance endorsement, regulated by your state’s insurance department, with standardised terms and clear rules on cancellation and pro-rata refunds.
What the dealer usually sells you is a gap waiver: a contract in which the lender agrees to waive the shortfall. It is often not insurance at all in the legal sense and is regulated differently, which is why in Texas it sits under a specific chapter of the Insurance Code rather than under normal auto insurance rules.
The practical consequence is that insurer gap tends to be standardised and predictable, whereas dealer gap terms vary wildly between products, and that variation is precisely where the surprises live.
One place the dealer product can genuinely win. Dealer waivers typically cover your full loan balance. Some insurer endorsements have payout caps. That is a genuine trade-off and we are not going to pretend otherwise, so if you rolled a lot of negative equity into this loan, read both sets of limits carefully rather than assuming that cheaper automatically means better.
Who Offers the Best Gap Insurance? State Farm, Progressive and the Surprises
Two of the most-searched names on this topic have answers that will surprise you.
State Farm does not sell gap insurance at all, neither as an endorsement nor in any other form. What it offers instead is Payoff Protector, which comes with State Farm Bank auto loans and cancels your remaining balance after a total loss claim. If you are a State Farm customer looking for gap on your policy, you are looking for something that is not there.
Progressive offers loan/lease payoff, which is not the same thing as gap. It may pay up to 25% of your car’s value after a total loss, depending on your state. That is a cap, and proper gap has no equivalent limit, so if your shortfall is bigger than a quarter of the car’s value, which it easily can be after rolling in negative equity, loan/lease payoff will not close it.
The general rule is that your own auto insurer is the cheapest source, followed by a credit union, with the dealership finishing last by a considerable margin. Third-party specialists also sell gap for roughly $150 to $350 covering the full term.
But check one thing before you buy anything: if you are leasing, your lease may already include gap. Most of them do, and buying it again means paying twice for identical protection. Toyota and Mazda leases are commonly cited exceptions, so read your own lease rather than assuming anything either way.
Is Gap Insurance Actually Worth It?
Often yes, and there is a clean test for it rather than a vague feeling.
The test is loan-to-value. If you owe more than the car is worth, gap has a job to do, and if you owe meaningfully less, it does not.
Buy gap if: you put down less than 20%, your loan runs 60 months or longer, you rolled negative equity from a trade-in, you are leasing, or you are driving a new car, luxury car or EV through its first two years of depreciation.
Skip gap if: you put 20% or more down, your loan is 48 months or shorter, or you bought used and the car’s value already matches the balance.
The reason gap exists at all is depreciation, because cars lose roughly 20% of their value in the first year and around 15% a year thereafter until year four or five. Your loan does not depreciate at all, so the two curves separate, and the space between them is the gap.
And it is not a rare problem. Edmunds has reported that more than one in four new-car trade-ins are upside down, meaning the owner owes more than the car is worth.
Here is what that actually looks like in practice. You finance $45,500 on a truck at 9% over 84 months, including $3,500 of negative equity rolled in from a trade, and twenty months later it is totalled. You still owe about $37,100, but the insurer values it at $30,800 and pays $30,300 after your deductible. You owe $6,800 on a truck you no longer have. Carrier gap, at $40 a year, would have cost you about $67 by that point and covered the entire shortfall.
That is exactly why gap is a good product, and also why paying $830 for it is so annoying when $67 was quietly available.
What Is the Downside of Gap Insurance?
The honest list, because this page is not a sales pitch.
It usually does not cover your deductible, which stays yours, though a few endorsements will reimburse it, so check yours.
It may not cover everything you rolled in. Negative equity from a previous car is not always covered, and dealer and insurer products treat it differently.
It may not cover interest accrued after the loss date, and that varies depending on the particular product.
You must carry comprehensive and collision, because gap sits on top of full coverage, which means a liability-only policy cannot have it.
There is usually a vehicle age limit, often around five to seven years.
Most people never claim it, which is true of all insurance and is still money out of your pocket.
And the biggest one: people keep paying for it long after it is useless. Gap becomes pointless the moment you have positive equity, and almost nobody cancels it at that moment because nobody tells them to.
How Long Does Gap Insurance Last, and Can I Buy It By Itself?
How long you need it is not a fixed term at all, because it lasts only until your loan balance drops below your car’s value, which for most people happens roughly two to three years in, after which you are paying for nothing whatsoever.
Set yourself a reminder and check your balance against Kelley Blue Book or NADA once a year, then cancel on the day the car is finally worth more than you owe.
Can you buy just gap by itself? Not from your insurer, because it is an endorsement that requires comprehensive and collision sitting underneath it. But standalone gap providers do exist and sell policies for roughly $150 to $350 for the full term, and credit unions sell it attached to a loan rather than a policy. So you have options beyond the finance office.
Gap Insurance Cost in Texas, California and Florida
The price is broadly similar everywhere, because gap is priced off your loan and your car rather than your postcode, so what actually changes between states is the regulation.
Texas is the clearest example, and a useful one for everyone. Chapter 1153 of the Texas Insurance Code governs dealer-sold gap agreements, requires disclosure, and requires a pro-rated refund when you cancel, pay off early, or trade in. If a refund does not arrive, the Texas Department of Insurance takes the complaint.
Other states regulate it differently, but the pro-rata refund right on dealer gap holds across all 50. Your state’s Department of Insurance is where you check the specifics and where you complain if something goes wrong.
If you are searching for gap insurance in the UK, note that this guide covers the US market. UK gap is a different product sold under a different regulatory regime, and the rules and pricing do not carry across.
What Should You Never Reveal to the Dealer When Negotiating?
This gets searched alongside gap for an obvious reason, which is that people work out afterwards that the finance office knew considerably more about them than they knew about it.
To be clear, this is not about lying, which you should never do and do not need to do, but about sequencing, and negotiating one thing at a time.
Do not lead with your monthly payment target. This is the big one. Say “I want to be around $450 a month” and you have handed over the whole negotiation, because payment is a number they can hit by stretching the loan term rather than lowering the price. A longer term means more interest, more depreciation exposure, and considerably more reason to sell you gap, so negotiate the price of the car and nothing else.
Do not discuss your trade-in until the price is agreed, because otherwise the two numbers get shuffled together and you can no longer see either one clearly.
Do not reveal how you are paying until the price is agreed, so keep cash or finance entirely separate from the negotiation.
Do not buy gap in the room where it is offered. You are perfectly entitled to say “I’ll think about it,” walk out, call your insurer, and add gap for $3 a month that same afternoon, and nothing bad happens because the car is still yours.
That last one is the only piece of dealer advice on this page that is actually about gap, and it is worth more than the rest combined.
The Honest Read: What to Actually Do
If you are about to buy a car: call your insurer before you go. Ask what gap costs as an endorsement. Get the number. Then when the finance office quotes you $700, you will know exactly what you are being asked to pay for convenience.
If you already bought dealer gap: check whether you can cancel today. Loan paid off, refinanced, traded in, or simply past the point of positive equity? That is unused premium sitting with your dealer. Ask for the cancellation form in writing.
If you are keeping the car and the loan: cancel the dealer product and add it to your policy instead, as long as you are still upside down. You get the pro-rata refund and the $3 a month version.
If you are leasing: read the lease before you buy anything. You probably already have gap and may be about to buy it twice.
If you have positive equity, cancel it today, because you are currently insuring a gap that no longer exists.
And if the refund stalls past eight weeks: in writing, then your state Department of Insurance. The CFPB has already documented that this process drags. You are not being difficult.
Final Word on What Gap Insurance Really Costs Per Month
Gap insurance is a genuinely good product sold, most of the time, at a genuinely bad price, in a room designed to make you stop asking questions.
The coverage is genuinely worth having if you are upside down on a car loan, which one in four new-car trade-ins are. It costs about three dollars a month from the company already insuring your car, or several hundred dollars plus interest plus five years of your attention from the finance office.
It is the same protection against the same total loss, producing the same cheque to the same lender.
If you bought the expensive one, you can probably get most of your money back and buy the cheap one this week. That is not a loophole at all, but a refund you are owed in all fifty states, and the only reason you have not claimed it is that nobody ever told you it was there.
FAQs
How much is gap insurance per month?
About $2 to $5 a month if you add it to your existing auto policy, which usually works out at $20 to $60 a year. Dealer gap costs $400 to $1,000 as a lump sum instead, and if it is rolled into your loan you pay interest on it, making a $700 policy cost roughly $830 over 60 months at 7%.
How much is gap insurance from a dealership?
Typically $400 to $1,000, charged as a single lump sum and usually financed into your car loan. That makes it roughly 7 to 10 times more expensive than the same coverage from your auto insurer, which charges $20 to $60 a year with no interest.
How much does gap raise your monthly payment?
A $700 gap policy financed over 60 months at 7% adds around $12 a month to your car payment. That small number is exactly why it is quoted that way, since the same coverage through your insurer costs about $3 a month with no interest attached.
Is gap insurance paid monthly or yearly?
It depends where you bought it. Through your auto insurer it is an endorsement billed with your normal premium, at $20 to $60 a year. Through a dealership it is a one-time lump sum for the life of the loan, and through a credit union usually a $200 to $400 one-time fee.
Do I get money back if I cancel my gap insurance?
Yes. Dealer-sold gap is refundable on a pro-rata basis in all 50 states, with a full refund typically available in a free-look window of 30 to 60 days. After that you get the unused portion back, prorated from the cancellation effective date, so delaying costs you money.
Can a dealership refuse to cancel gap insurance?
No. Your right to a pro-rata refund of unused coverage is real, and some states write it into statute, such as Chapter 1153 of the Texas Insurance Code. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau has documented that delays are common, so put the request in writing and escalate to your state Department of Insurance if needed.
How do I cancel dealer gap insurance and get a refund?
Contact the dealership’s finance and insurance department, request the cancellation form, and provide your current odometer reading plus proof of payoff if the loan is settled. Expect 4 to 8 weeks, with the refund going to the lienholder if a balance remains or to you if it does not.
Why do dealerships push gap insurance?
Because the finance and insurance office is far more profitable than selling the car itself, and gap carries a heavy markup that works because most buyers do not know it is available elsewhere for a tenth of the price. It is presented after long negotiations, when buyers are tired and want the keys.
Does State Farm offer gap insurance?
No. State Farm does not sell gap insurance at all. It offers Payoff Protector on State Farm Bank auto loans instead, which cancels your remaining balance after a total loss claim, so State Farm customers looking for a gap endorsement are looking for something that does not exist.
Is Progressive’s loan/lease payoff the same as gap insurance?
No. Progressive offers loan/lease payoff, which may pay up to 25% of your car’s value after a total loss, depending on your state. That cap means it will not close a shortfall larger than a quarter of the car’s value, which is possible if you rolled negative equity into the loan.
Is gap insurance actually worth it?
Yes if you owe more than the car is worth, which applies if you put less than 20% down, have a loan of 60 months or longer, rolled in negative equity, or are leasing. Skip it if you put 20% or more down, have a 48-month or shorter loan, or bought used with a balance matching the value.
What is the downside of gap insurance?
It usually does not cover your deductible, may not cover all rolled-in negative equity or interest after the loss date, and requires you to carry comprehensive and collision. The biggest downside is that people keep paying for it long after they reach positive equity and it has stopped doing anything.
How long does gap insurance last?
Not a fixed term. It lasts until your loan balance drops below your car’s value, which is usually about two to three years into a typical loan. Check your balance against Kelley Blue Book or NADA once a year, and cancel the day the car is worth more than you owe.
Can I purchase just gap insurance by itself?
Not from your auto insurer, since it is an endorsement that requires comprehensive and collision underneath it. Standalone gap providers do exist and sell policies for roughly $150 to $350 for the full term, and credit unions sell it attached to the loan rather than to a policy.
Do I need gap insurance if I lease a car?
Probably not separately, because most leases already include or require gap coverage. Buying it again means paying twice for the same protection. Toyota and Mazda leases are commonly cited exceptions, so read your lease agreement rather than assuming either way.
About the Author
Md Shahinuzzaman is an Insurance and Out-of-Pocket Healthcare Cost Specialist with 16 years of experience in banking and insurance. He writes plain-English guides that help people understand what they are being charged and why. Every figure on this page traces to a named source, and where a number cannot be verified, it is not published. This article is general information and not financial or legal advice. Reviewed July 2026.
Sources
Edmunds, negative equity in trade-ins research: https://www.edmunds.com/
Compare.com, Gap Insurance: Cost, Coverage and Where to Buy: https://www.compare.com/auto-insurance/resources/coverage/gap-insurance
Hotaling Insurance, How Much Is Gap Insurance Per Month: https://hotalinginsurance.com/gap-insurance/how-much-is-gap-insurance-per-month
Hotaling Insurance, Gap Insurance Refunds and Cancellation: https://hotalinginsurance.com/gap-insurance/cost-value-gap-insurance-refunds-and-cancellation-what-to-know
Hotaling Insurance, Dealership Gap vs Credit Union Gap: https://hotalinginsurance.com/his-blogs%E2%80%8B/providers-dealership-gap-insurance-vs-credit-union-gap-insurance
A-LA Auto Insurance, Gap Insurance Texas Cost and Coverage: https://alaautoinsurance.com/blog/gap-insurance-texas-explained
A-LA Auto Insurance, How Much Does Gap Insurance Cost in Texas: https://alaautoinsurance.com/answers/gap-insurance-texas-cost
InsuredBetter, What Is Gap Insurance: Cost and How It Works: https://www.insuredbetter.com/car-insurance/auto-coverage-types/gap/
LA Insurance, How Much Is Gap Insurance: https://lainsurance.com/blog/how-much-is-gap-insurance
Texas Insurance Code, Chapter 1153 (Guaranteed Asset Protection Waivers): https://statutes.capitol.texas.gov/Docs/IN/htm/IN.1153.htm
Texas Department of Insurance: https://www.tdi.texas.gov/
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Supervisory Highlights: https://www.consumerfinance.gov/compliance/supervisory-highlights/
Kelley Blue Book, vehicle depreciation and values: https://www.kbb.com/
